Best Fudge Brownie:
This brownie mix was a clear favorite with our test panel. Not only were there excessive "oohs" and "aahs,” this little brownie packs an over-the-top chocolate punch with great texture and a true dark chocolate taste. As one of our taste testers put it, "Wow! The best part is that while I could eat half a pan of the others, I could probably only eat two or three of these. There's so much fudge!"
Runners Up:
Fluffy and gooey, Betty’s fudge brownies are a close second to our winner. These brownies are very soft and moist, with good texture and a smooth chocolaty fudge flavor. "If I didn't want to go through all of the work to make the Ghirardelli brownies, this would be my go to mix," one panel member said.
With a very soft texture, these dense brownies have a somewhat spicy flavor. "It has a slight anise taste," said one of our testers.
While it may look like a brownie your Grandma would make, these brownies are rather dry and fall apart. There also wasn't enough fudge for our taste testers: "It just didn't knock my socks off."
*Roundy's Chocolate Fudge Brownies
These brownies have a rather cakey consistency that holds together well. However, when it comes to flavor, this lacks that rich chocoalte taste that our panelists were looking for.
*Roundy’s is a generic store bought brand in Southeastern Wisconsin
Maybe it was because they were fat free, but these brownies received little praise. With a rather cakey and pasty consistency, it's hard to taste the chocolate flavor.
Want to make your brownies from scratch? Try this chocolaty Fudge Brownie recipe.
Looking for more sweet desserts?
