Monday, November 23, 2009

Working moms and the Mommy Drive-By: Why do we do this to one another?

Getty Images

Getty Images

We've all experienced it at one time or another: The Mommy Drive-By. When someone -- a relative, another mom, a total stranger -- takes it upon herself to question your judgment or criticize your parenting.

Single moms get flak about their social lives. Step moms are looked down upon for not being "a real parent." Breast-feeding mamas get hit when they nurse their child in public; formula-feeding mothers get the evil eye when they whip out a bottle instead of a breast. Mothers from all walks of life are questioned for decisions large and small. And working mothers, well, they get a little bit of "all of the above."

I'm positive that I thought I knew more about parenting before I became a parent, so I can kind of see why non-parents feel compelled to tell parents what they should do differently, whether they are qualified to say anything or not. But when the drive-by comes from another working mom, I'm baffled... why do we do this to one another?

One mom told me that I'm much too lenient with my kids, but "you can't help it, you don't get to see them much because you're always working." Another once told our older kids that she loved her kids enough to stay home, leaving my big kids to question my commitment to them. When my husband and I worked different shifts to cover childcare, I was criticized for "tag-team parenting" and being "too busy to be a good mother."

Drive-byes don't always happen in person, either. I got hit by a drive-by online a couple of weeks ago by someone who has never met me before. My post about my preschooler and how her "Mama Drama" slays me sparked this comment: "Wouldn't it be easier to stay with your toddler and give her compassion and love from her mom, rather than drop her off with a stranger? Try being a Stay at Home Mom."

(For one thing, it's my preschooler, not my toddler. For another, anyone who thinks being a stay-at-home mom is "easier" is probably neither at home all day nor a mom.)

The daycare question always triggers interesting drive-byes for working moms, with plenty of shrapnel to tweeze out of your flesh days and even weeks later. Recently, I was taken to task for saying that my youngest two kids go to preschool instead of just calling it daycare.

Never mind that my preschooler is actually in, well, preschool, and my toddler is in the daycare portion of that same facility. This person told me that she thinks I call it a school because it makes me feel and look better about what I'm "doing to" my kids.

I thought I'd be furious, but I wasn't. I was surprised by the source of the drive-by, but mostly I was just tired. I pointed out that different solutions work for different people and suggested that, until she was faced with having to make the decision herself, it would make sense for her to stop criticizing me for mine. Then I changed the subject.

These drive-byes don't make me question my judgment. But I sure am tired of being asked to defend it.

Have you been hit by a mommy drive-by? How did you handle it?

Lylah M. Alphonse is a full-time editor, a freelance writer, and mom and step mom to five kids. She writes about juggling career and parenthood at The 36-Hour Day on Work It, Mom!, and blogs about writing at Write. Edit. Repeat.

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 58
  • springtime's Avatar
    Posted by springtime Tue Aug 19, 2008 8:08am PDT

    For some odd reason, once a child emerges from the birth canal, that woman assumes she is an authority on labor, delivery, and all aspects of child rearing..... of ALL chidren she encounters. Women do what they have to do to take care of their children and make certain their well being is always first. That may be daycare... that may be staying home.... that may be " tag team parenting".

    These busy bodies deserve no attention, no answer and certainly no explanation. To do so would indicate you believe they have a valid point.

    Report Abuse
  • Shonda's Avatar
    Posted by Shonda Tue Aug 19, 2008 8:11am PDT

    I love the little old ladys who always have a comment. "She should be wearing a hat." "It's to warm out for her to be in pants" Blah Blah Blah. Haters will always hate because they are sad and bored with there own lives. We are americans which means we are free to live our lives the way we want. If anyone else has a problem, tell them to give you a paycheck every week so you can stay home and still pay the rent, hell while your at it tell them to buy your gas, clothes, medical, dental, and groceries too! If your child is clothed, fed, and for the most part happy, your doing things right.

    Report Abuse
  • Lindsey's Avatar
    Posted by Lindsey Tue Aug 19, 2008 8:17am PDT

    Hello! I hope you are well. I'm not a parent myself, but two of my closet girl friends are. Its so weird to see how different they are raising their children. One is a two time mother, her's are 3 and 5; the other is a new one time mother, her angel is a month old. Both of them are awsome people but they are very different people as well. I've noticed with the mother of two that she has less patience with her children, tends to yell and curse alot at them but she hardly ever spanks them...The mother of the new born is just beside herself with nervousness. Of course, that could be in part because the baby is a new born so she hasn't slept in weeks...:) I can't say which is right or which is wrong...but the mother of the new born is going back to work in 2 weeks and is looking forward to it, while the mother of the two older children hasn't worked in a long time....and having the children 24/7 minus when she can get a sitter is wearing her thin. She is looking for employment now. Part of me thinks that even though they are your child, your blood and your life, its just like anything else. You spend to much time around them, it starts to erk your nerves. I believe that women that work actually appreciate their gift of a child more because distance makes the heart grow fonder. That's simply my opinion of course, like I say, I don't know how it would be because I have no children. I do see your point though, other mothers do things very differently, but as long as the child isn't in danger or being harmed or forgotten about then no one has the right to say anything to you about how you run your life. God gave you your life, and he gave you your children...they are yours and yours alone, so just tell people to shut up and mind their own. Good luck to you!!!

    Report Abuse
  • Mysterious Gryphon's Avatar
    Posted by Mysterious Gryphon Tue Aug 19, 2008 10:08am PDT

    Lylah -

    Since I'm the one who posted the comment you mention here, I thought I should explain it a bit. No, I don't have children, but I used to teach preschool, and watching little kids cry because they missed their moms really broke my heart. I would have to try to hug them and kiss their booboos, and I wondered how these children's moms could not want to be there to do it - how they would feel if they saw their toddler come to Miss E- for a hug when they were sad.

    One of the reasons I don't want to become a mother is that I know I would want to be with my children 24 hours a day, and if I couldn't then I would have to endure knowing that another woman was drying my baby's tears.

    That's what I meant when I think it would be easier to stay at home with them.

    Report Abuse
  • SharonW's Avatar
    Posted by SharonW Tue Aug 19, 2008 10:20am PDT

    Why is it the fathers never get this question, "How can you leave your children with strangers?" Instead it's the mothers and I'll tell you my answer: Because I am protecting my children. If I stayed home it would be selfish of me. I would get the superiority complex that comes with this "sacrifice" and my children would be vulnerable. If daddy has a heart attack or gets laid off or runs off with some chickie, how will mom keep them off food stamps? I would have walked away from my contacts and career and for 10 years now would have been out of the workforce and left with limited marketable skills. That's dangerous. I am my kid's backup plan. They are loved, they have a great support system and we are raising them, not their teachers.

    Report Abuse
  • Marty's Avatar
    Posted by Marty Tue Aug 19, 2008 11:58am PDT

    MG wrote:

    "I wondered how these children's moms could not want to be there to do it"

    It's not a matter of not wanting to be with their children, some mothers don't have a choice. Either work, or let your child starve. Not everyone wants to be on welfare to feed and clothe their children.

    Report Abuse
  • Lylah M. Alphonse's Avatar
    Posted by Lylah M. Alphonse Tue Aug 19, 2008 12:06pm PDT

    Ladies, thank you for your insightful comments!

    Mysterious Gryphon, thank you especially... I appreciate your taking the time to explain what you meant, and I can see your point of view. Thank you for sharing that.

    Report Abuse
  • Rosemary's Avatar
    Posted by Rosemary Tue Aug 19, 2008 1:58pm PDT

    Everyone handles their life the way that best works for them. I try to find the positive in something that can seem so negative to others. Maybe a working mom, especially one that is happy with her work, is a great example to her children - to her daughters - that women can provide and contribute to the family in many ways. I feel like I am a better mother because I love my work and I share this with my kids. I show them what I do and tell them how my day was which sparks them to tell me how their day was. I respect all women however they handle motherhood, as long as they are respectful and loving to their children.

    Report Abuse
  • Sarah Y's Avatar
    Posted by Sarah Y Tue Aug 19, 2008 3:00pm PDT

    I'm a SAHM, but my thought is simply this: being a mom is hard enough w/o the criticism. I don't know if I ever gave anyone advice before, but I sure wouldn't do it now. Every time someone drives by and gives me their opinion, it feels like a slap in the face. Trust me, if I want an opinion, I ask. Otherwise, mind your own!

    Report Abuse
  • mabcosmic's Avatar
    Posted by mabcosmic Tue Aug 19, 2008 5:22pm PDT

    This is a wonderful post. I agree with it all, but I do feel that women from all walks of life are often at the recieving end of unnecessary criticism.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 58

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Health Byte

Are your feet aching? Do you suffer from plantar fasciitis or varicose veins? Relief could be as simple as stretching your toes.