Love + Sex

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Are modern men wimps? Also: Who cares if they are?

In the opening lines of his new book, "Manthropology: The Science of the Inadequate Modern Male,"  anthropologist Peter McAllister writes, "If you're reading this then you--or the male you have bought it for--are the worst man in history. No ifs, no buts--the worst man, period...As a class we are in fact the sorriest cohort of masculine Homo sapiens to ever walk the planet."

CRIPES!

McAllister's theory has more to do with  physicality--things like strength, speed, and endurance--than it does modern man's emotional state or intellectual acuity. The Australian scientist based his research on a variety of sources--from 20,000-year-old fossilized footprints to photographs taken as recently as early last century--and concluded that all of our male ancestors could run faster, jump higher, and row harder than any men living today, even our most well-trained athletes.

"We are so inactive these days and have been since the industrial revolution really kicked into gear," McAllister told Reuters. "These people were much more robust than we were."

McAllister's sad, flabby reality makes sense, really, when you consider that most men spend their lives sitting in front of computers, not out hunting for food. However, the fact that this weakness, or "wimpiness," isn't really men's fault (our societies have changed! We're all softer and lazier!), hasn't stopped some women writers from pouncing on McAllister's findings and using them as an excuse to bash our male counterparts.

Take, for example, columnist Liz Jones who wrote in yesterday's Daily Mail:
"Modern man has evolved, due to his love of cars and fast food, into a blob with all the muscle tone and definition of a slug...These men might all wear trainers and tracksuits and workwear such as denim jeans and combat trousers, but it is all just dressing up, an illusion, a hark back to the days when men actually knew how to do physical things like, ooh, I don't know, put in a light bulb or change a duvet cover or make love to a woman."

She goes on to say, "What poor, sad creatures modern men are. What wimps. What wastes of space."

Whoa! Bitter much, lady?

Now, I don't know what kind of world Ms. Jones is living in, but honestly, I don't need my husband to be able to throw a javelin, protect me from wildebeests, or row our canoe quickly to safety while we're being chased by some prehistoric Swamp Thing. What I do need is for him to listen to what I'm saying, to understand who I am, to love me monogamously, to earn money so he can share the bills, and to sometimes fix the WiFi when the modem goes down. And these are things he can accomplish whether he's a wimp, a slug, or, even, the sorriest masculine Homo sapien ever to walk the Earth.
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 110
  • SurferRob's Avatar
    Posted by SurferRob Mon Oct 19, 2009 5:01pm PDT

    Amazing how we used to be knuckle-dragging Neaderthals and sexists pigs.

    As a former Army officer I'd love to blow Liz's stereotype out of the water...I'd like to think we've evolved - hell I can even cook.

    So, should men pine for the days of submissive, meek women that can only pump out kids, cook my meals and give an opinion after we tell them what it is?

    Report Abuse
  • SILENT KNIGHT's Avatar
    Posted by SILENT KNIGHT Mon Oct 19, 2009 5:46pm PDT

    Modern Men are as much wimps as thier counter parts. I promise you when you find a weak man there is a weaker woman near by, be it his mother, girlfriend, wife or close associate. I don't understand why women baby or pet grown men and expect them to act thier age. Treat a Man like a Man and you wont have to worry about him acting like anything less. Besides that you can usually find a strong Man close to a strong Woman or they are on thier way to each other. If you are a woman complaining about how weak the Men you've met are then I suggest you change whatever it is in you that would attract the cowards you can't stand. They must not be that weak if their Man enough to approach a real Woman, because I don't think a coward could get one. It's sad to see a grown woman in a lesbian relationship with a grown man, but if she likes it, then I love it and hope they both get everything in life they deserve.

    Report Abuse
  • Lil Boo's Avatar
    Posted by Lil Boo Mon Oct 19, 2009 6:32pm PDT

    I do not believe that the men of our times are wimps. I believe society has changed and so has EVERYONE else. We cannot focus only on men in this category. That article deals with outdated ideas. I feel that men/women are strong and some are weak, but do not isolate one gender.

    Report Abuse
  • Christopher's Avatar
    Posted by Christopher Mon Oct 19, 2009 6:45pm PDT

    Sure modern man may not be a fit as our ancestors but they had to be, because the average life expectancy was around 40-45 years old. Hell modern man has eliminated more different species then our ancestors could even imagine. Mankind didn't become top of the food chain until modern man made his appearance. Look at military strategy since the American Revolution. They lost so many men because they stood shoulder to shoulder and marched in a line firing weapons that had one shot a piece. With the knowledge that modern man possesses about combat, one solider, marine, sailor, etc. would be a commander in ancient times. Not to mention the nuclear and biological weapons that the modern man has access to. WIMPS, I don't think so!! There was no such thing as "Mutually Assured Destruction " until modern man.

    Report Abuse
  • Zom-B's Avatar
    Posted by Zom-B Mon Oct 19, 2009 6:53pm PDT

    Most of them? Yes. Me? No.

    Report Abuse
  • Dubs's Avatar
    Posted by Dubs Mon Oct 19, 2009 7:19pm PDT

    Hilarious. (Here's a finger for you Liz and Peter)

    ..I..

    We could really care less about what you think. LOL, morons.

    Report Abuse
  • Zencoz's Avatar
    Posted by Zencoz Mon Oct 19, 2009 7:31pm PDT

    it is, to some sort i do see many city-towners guys today are wimpy, at the least by their inferiority in physical state (though not all of them). but who cares, because not so many women cares about it either when it comes to relationship - if i want to put it up, there are more big-bellied men have a better life, and a better relationship than those who are, physically sturdy. and i also want to point this out: do do women prefer the idealism of having a perfectly well-built mate and exchange it for the understanding, partnership, and i'm-ready-to-listen-what-you-want-to-say-dear kind of guy?

    maybe this idealism came to counter the perspective of what we men have in mind: to have the sexiest, or at the least better girlfriend than my other friend. but then, it is just one perspective when what we wanted is just the same with what women wanted all along: someone who will accept us thoroughly - no matter how big bellied we men may become one day because of too much beer.

    and i think (sorry to say this, but i must point it out for men justification and to make my statement free from the essence of biase) that if, a woman wants a masculine and a muscular partner, reflect yourself in a mirror and ask: mirror mirror on the wall, who's the fairest of them all? - try to imply that 'fair' word in other meaning.

    Report Abuse
  • BlueEyes's Avatar
    Posted by BlueEyes Mon Oct 19, 2009 7:37pm PDT

    I hate say this, but there's something sexy about a smart nerdy man...

    Report Abuse
  • KittyKat's Avatar
    Posted by KittyKat Mon Oct 19, 2009 7:46pm PDT

    Actually its not just the men its the women too who are becoming wimps thinks to computers and technology. Instead of going out and being productive or going out and having fun, most people think sitting at home playing on the computer is fun when its not.

    Report Abuse
  • tbone64's Avatar
    Posted by tbone64 Mon Oct 19, 2009 9:02pm PDT

    So has all of mankind become braindead with the advances in technology? We rely on computers for practically every aspect of our lives. How many of us can go a week- no, better yet, a day- without our cell phones or computers? Can we really survive without emails and Facebook? How far behind will we be if we don't log on and find out who has sent us something? We would be lost without Twitter! Why not just say that our brains are becoming globs of gelatin within our skulls?

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 110

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?